Amsterdam Ave
Our Amsterdam Avenue location is the heart of the Upper West Side’s kosher tradition, serving up kettle-boiled bagels and hand-sliced lox in a warm, community-focused atmosphere. Whether you’re stopping in for a morning coffee or picking up a catering spread, we bring a “white-glove” touch to every neighborhood favorite.
Our Amsterdam Avenue Location A Neighborhood Favorite
Located in the heart of the Upper West Side, our Amsterdam Avenue location offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can savor the authentic taste of New York. Start your day with a freshly baked bagel and a cup of rich, aromatic coffee. Or, indulge in a hearty lunch, choosing from a variety of delicious sandwiches, salads, and soups. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, our Amsterdam Avenue deli is the perfect place to experience the Bagels & Co. difference.
The Gold Standard of Kosher Catering on Amsterdam Avenue
Redefine your hosting experience with the sophisticated culinary heritage of a true New York landmark. Our Amsterdam Avenue location specializes in providing elite, full-service Kosher catering tailored for high-profile corporate functions, milestone family celebrations, and boutique Upper West Side gatherings. We offer an uncompromising selection of kettle-boiled bagels, hand-carved smoked fish, and artisanal Cholov Yisroel dairy platters, all presented with the precision and elegance your event deserves. Entrust your menu to our experts and experience the perfect fusion of tradition and contemporary professionalism.
Our Menu
Small is for 10 – 15 people – Medium is for 20 – 25 people – Large is for 30 – 35 people
-
Cream Cheese Platter Small: $75.00 / Medium: $90.00 / Large: $105.00
Assorted Cream Cheeses: Plain, Vegetable, Scallion, Olive, or Lox Spread
-
Hard Cheese Platter Small: $65.00 / Medium: $75.00 / Large: $85.00
Mozzarella, American, Muenster & Swiss
-
Combo Platter Small: $85.00 / Medium: $95.00 / Large: $110.00
Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, and White Fish Salad
-
Smoked Fish Platter Small: $175.00 / Medium: $210.00 / Large: $240.00
Whole White Fish, Sable and Lox (Small Platter Only has Lox and Sable)
-
Vegetable Platter Small: $60.00 / Medium: $75.00 / Large: $80.00
Stick or sliced: Cucumber, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Carrots and Pepper
-
Mediterranean Salad Platter (Pick 3): Small: $65.00 / Medium: $80.00 / Large: $85.00
Tehini, Hummus, Babaganush Turkish Salad, Matbucha or Spanish Eggplant
-
Fruit Platter Small: $70.00 / Medium: $80.00 / Large: $90.00
Assorted Seasonal Fruits
-
Omelets Wraps Platter Small: $80.00 / Medium: $105.00 / Large: $120.00
Spinach, Cheese, Scallion, Vegetable, Wrapped with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion and Home Fries
-
Assorted Wraps Platter Small: $90.00 / Medium: $130.00 / Large: $165.00
Assorted Wraps, Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, White Fish Salad, Baked Salmon Salad, Grilled Vegetable & Hummus, Hard Cheese
Small is for 10 – 15 people – Medium is for 20 – 25 people – Large is for 30 – 35 people
Some platters may be justified per serving
-
Stuffed Sandwiches Small: $75.00 / Medium: $95.00 / Large: $120.00
Homemade Foccacia Bread Filled with Pesto Sauce, Mozarella, Melanza Sauce, Eggplant, Avocado or Tuna
-
Salad Bowl Small: $65.00 / Large: $100.00
Greek, Israeli, Caesar, Israeli Tuna, Garden
-
Pastas Small: $70.00 / Large: $100.00
Pesto Sauce, Vodka, Primavera, Marinara, Fungi, Alie Olio Alfredo
-
Lasagna Small: $70.00 / Large: $105.00
Marinara Sauce & Cheese, Vegetable, Spinach or Eggplant
-
Homemade Quiche Small: $55.00.Large: $90.00
Mushrooms & Spinaxh, Zucchini & Yellow Squash, Broccoli & More
-
Pizza 20" Plain: $22.00
20" Toppings: $29.00
20" Whole Wheat Plain: $30.00
20" Whole Wheat Toppings: $34.00 -
Shakshuka Small: $65.00 / Large: $100.00
Eggs Cooked with Tomatoes, Garlic, Herbs & Peppers
-
Omletes Small: $70.00 / Large: $100.00
Mushrooms, Cheese, Spinach, Vegetables
-
Homemade Fries Small: $55.00 / Large: $80.00
Baked Potato with our special Spices, Onions & Peppers
-
Cole Slaw Small: $60.00 / Large: $80.00
Small is for 10 – 15 people – Medium is for 20 – 25 people – Large is for 30 – 35 people
-
Bagel and Bialy Small (10 Bagels): $25.00 / Medium (15 Bagels): $35.00 / Large (20 Bagels): $45.00
Assorted Bagels Cut into Quarters
-
Bakery Basket Small: $55.00 / Medium: $70.00 / Large: $80.00
Homemade Baked Cookies, Danishes or Muffins
-
Homemade Blintez Small: $70.00 / Medium: $100.00 / Large: $120.00
Filled with Soft Sweet Cream Cheese
-
Burekas Small: $55.00 / Medium: $80.00 / Large: $90.00
Assorted Burekas Filled with Cheese, Spinach, Potato, Peppers and Mushrooms
-
Homemade Pancakes Small: $60.00 / Large: $105.00
Information
HOURS
Sunday – Thursday: 6:30 am – 9 pm
Friday: 6:30 am – 1 pm
Closed on Saturday